Essay topic:
Evaluate The Value Of Pre-School Education In The Development Of Young Children.
This essay discusses the primary principles and values of preschool education. The importance of preschool education and its conflicts with out of home services such as childcare centres will be evaluated. It is asserted here that the principle differences between the forms of prior to school education are the role of qualified teachers in a school setting (Brown, 2008, p.2, para.8) and teacher’s specialism to interpret curriculum (Perry, Dockett and Harley, 2007, p.117).
Some people have different opinions about preschool and child care centres. Often people say children should stay at home with their parents. Others believe that government should not provide sources for every child’s education (Brown, 2008, p.2, para.8). This debate about preschool education and childcare centres requires evidence based on studies to prove that pre-school is effective and has a great impact on children’s future learning (Brown, 2008, p.2, para.8).
There are two types of early childhood services in New South Wales, childcare centres and preschools (Burgess, 2008, para.2). Preschool is usually clarified by its relationship to childcare centres. This task requires an understanding of long day-care centres which will be discussed below. Preschool may be described as school for children that can include school programs and long day- care programs. Preschool provides educational and developmental programs during school hours for children three to five years old. After completing preschool, children attend full time primary schools (Biddle, 2007, pp. 9-10 and Burgess, 2008, para. 3).
On the other hand, childcare centres can be a form of preschool with the purpose of providing assistance to parents with their child-minding role. Childcare centres are established as family day care or centre-based long day care centres (Burgess, 2008, para. 5). Childcare centres are often referred to as societal institutions that separate children from adult socio-cultural communities (Brennan, 2007, p.2).
According to Centre for Community Child Health- Royal Children’s Hospital (CCCH RCH) (2008a), School preparation is necessary, because children need to build up the competence and necessary skills to be ready to attend primary school. Preschool prepares children with these prerequisite skills and competencies for primary school (Burgess, 2008, para. 7-8). The successful learning experiences before school has a great impact on children’s long term goals and ongoing learning environment (CCCH RCH, 2008c, para.3-4). Whilst children may develop these skills in childcare centres or in the home environment, they also learn from each other in a school setting (CCCH RCH, 2008a, para.1). The important difference is the role of a qualified teacher. At preschool, staff are required to have teaching qualifications from university. A qualified teacher has speciality and training in child development and education (Burgess, 2008, para.7, 12). In contrast, because of staff-child ratios and the cost of having a qualified teacher, long day care centres require childcare workers only to have TAFE qualifications (Burgess, 2008, para. 8).
A qualified early childhood teacher’s role in preschool education is critical (Raban, 2000, cited on Biddle, 2007, p.11). Teachers provide opportunities and experiences for children to expand physical, social, emotional and intellectual development. Experiences are based on individual children’s interests, past learning experiences and strengths, states Centre for Community Child Health- Royal Children’s Hospital (CCCH RCH) (2008b, para. 12). Children at preschool learn about mathematics, language, science and social studies through games, music, artwork and books (Burgess, 2008, para.17-18). Teachers at preschool monitor children’s performances to make sure that they receive the best education and learn through their experiences. Teachers provide support to children who have difficulties with social and emotional skills, particularly children who are at risk of failing at school (CCCH RCH, 2008b, para. 12). Children at risk of failing are from families with low income and who may not be able to provide necessary services for their children’s education (Brown, 2008, para.4).
Children at child care centres will have similar opportunities. Childcare programmes have measurable impacts on children through the first year of schooling and for many into their third year, especially large improvements for those students considered ‘at risk’ (Raban, 2000, cited in Biddle, 2007, p.11). Children may develop self-esteem, appropriate social behaviour and better performance cognitively in literacy and numeracy during the early years of schooling. Children may receive consistent education from their qualified parents about songs or nursery rhymes, reading books, letters and numbers (Raban, 2000, cited in Biddle, 2007, p.11 and CCCH RCH, 2008a, para. 2). However in preschool children follow a planned program based on an academic curriculum that defines learning and developmental goals, which are implemented by qualified teachers (Perry, Dockett and Harley, 2007, p.117). Curriculum provides learning opportunities for children to learn consistently about all aspects of literacy and numeracy, problem solving, decision making and thinking skills (Walker, 2008, para.11-13).
Staff in childcare centres may not have the level of training or understanding required to interpret curriculum documents. McCain, Mustard and Shanker (2007, p.17) indicate that “ the roots of economic productivity and health risks in adulthood are found in early childhood” (cited in Perry, Dockett and Harley, 2007, p.118).
Attending preschool has a great effect on young children’s developmental skills such as social, emotional, maturity, self esteem, and future educational achievements (Kronemann, Hull and Edsall, 2001, cited in Biddle, 2007, p. 11). Children will be ready to start primary school with no pressure and anxiety (Barnett,1995 and Boocock 1995 cited in Biddle, 2007, p. 11). Prior to school educations stimulates enthusiasm and high self-esteem in young children ( Hickman, Stixurd and Urzua cited in Biddle, 2007, page 11).
There are two well-cited longitudinal research studies are done in United States (USA). The ‘High/Scope Perry School Study (HSPS)’ and the other in United Kingdom (UK), ‘The Effective Provision of Preschool Education (EPPE)’. These studies provide fundamental principles to the Australian education system (Harrington, 2008, para.1).
The HSPS study was done among 123 children from African American families from ages 3 to 11, at ages 14-15, at ages 19-27 and most recently at age 40. The aim of this study was to evaluate whether pre-school education offers short and long term progress and advantage to young children who experience adversity and are at risk of failing in school. The children were split in two groups, one group of children received high quality preschool program and the other group was with no preschool program (Harrington, 2008, para. 1).
According to the HSPS study, the group with educational program achieved higher scores in various intellectual and language tests from their preschool years up to age 7 and school achievement at ages 9, 10 and 14. Also these children had better attitudes toward school at ages 15-19 which meant as a result they could do better in general literacy between ages 19-27. Furthermore their general level of education was higher by age 27 (Harrington, 2008, para. 2). Moreover at age 40 this group achieved higher employment rates, better earnings, home ownership, more savings accounts, and fewer crimes across all categories (Harrington, 2008, para. 3).
The UK study was done among 3000 children, their parents, home environments and school settings they attended to investigate the effective provision of preschool education EPPE. The two groups of children were compared, one group with no or minimal preschool experience and the other group with preschool experience (Harrington, 2008, and CCCH RCH, 2008a, para. 1).
The group of children with preschool experience had better intellectual and social behavioural development. Furthermore this group of children had the opportunity to socialise with children from different backgrounds (Harrington, 2008, para. 2).
From the HSPS and EPPE studies, it has been proven that preschool education has a long term impact in children’s future learning’s, school completion, employment, stability in relationships and lower mental illnesses. However children who do not attend preschool may not have these advantages (CCCH RCH, 2008a, para.15).
In conclusion preschool learning is necessary for children before entering full time primary school. Preschool is beneficial for children in all areas of development mainly in terms of social, emotional and cognitive development. This applies to children from different backgrounds including those children who are at risk of failing at school. Preschool provides prior to school educational requirements of primary school as a result children of which can benefit in kindergarten and later stages of education. However, long day care centres require childcare workers only to have TAFE qualifications. In childcare centres staff provides good thinking and socialising opportunities for children. They may not have the level of training to interpret the curriculum and lay foundations for planned goals to teach children.
The most important differences among preschools and childcare centres are the role of a qualified teachers and developmental programs based on curriculum. In preschool children follow a planned program based on an academic curriculum that defines learning and developmental goals, which are implemented by qualified teachers.